Tuesday, November 25, 2008

#4 - Desk Crit (Recieved)

from Trudian Trail
to natoxica@uga.edu
date Fri, Nov 14, 2008 at 3:42 PM
subject Desk Crit


Hello Natasha,

I was completely impressed with your project. We had spoke briefly about it in yesterday's showcase and my general reaction to it was one of amazement. The overall design is very professional and is comparable to software that you can currently find out on the market.

Your action script skills are also very impressive and help to make the program even more interactive. I like that the guy moves during the actual user interaction section (it was a good surprise!) I also just noticed that he blinks. These are very simple things, but it really helps to motivate the learner.

Really I don't have much feedback on what you can improve. As you already know I would just say work on the introduction and instruction text.

Another very minor note ( I am not sure if this was intentional, but in the copyright text you have 'CityPLanner' instead of 'CityPlanner'. It's not a big deal, but I figured since I saw it I would just let you know!
GREAT JOB so far and I can't wait to see the final product at showcase.
---------------------------------------
Trudian Trail
E-mail: surp0526@uga.edu, trudiantrail@hotmail.com
Phone: 904-210-0666

#3 - Desk Crit (Recieved)

from Sean Boyle
to natoxica@uga.edu
date Fri, Nov 14, 2008 at 10:25 AM
subject Desk Crit


Hi Natasha,
Thanks for letting me take a look at your project. I think it looks really great. The colors and layout are excellent and your animation and drawing skills are great - especially Joe! I can tell that you are really passionate about your subject as well as the educational concepts/theory behind the project. It does remind me of the Sim City concept and I like the fact that you are giving users the power to control their budget/citizen happiness and see the direct result of changes on each.

I know you are still in the process of creating this but I might offer a few suggestions:

1. Maybe some more explanation of the indicators (a rollover definition perhaps). I know the pollution, taxes and travel time are pretty obvious but the fourth may not be. And also, certain users who are less aware/knowledgeable of these concepts may need an explanation of all four.

2. I know you're probably working on the feedback section but I wanted to comment that an explanation of why an increase of a certain investment line affects the budget and citizen satisfaction would be useful as well. For instance, an increase in cars raises pollution and lowers travel time/local development. An explanation of exactly why would be useful for visitors.

3. I know you mentioned you were planning on creating further explanations of each investment area. I think that's a great idea and takes the site beyond a learning tool about budgets and then adds a public awareness/education component that will be really great.

Overall, I think the site looks excellent and I'm looking forward to seeing it at the Showcase.

Take care,
Sean

#2 - Desk Crit (Recieved)

from Jea H. Choi
to natoxica@uga.edu
date Tue, Nov 11, 2008 at 12:19 AM
subject Late Desk Crit

Hello,
I am so sorry to give a desk crit late.
I wrote this on a project day, but I did not have a chance to send it.
Anyway, here is my desk crit.


Reviewed Date: 10/23/08
Project Title: City Planner
Designer’s Name: Natasha Barreto
Project link: http://natoxica.myweb.uga.edu/cityplanner.html


Critique :
Your site looks awesome! It looks so professional. I like the color scheme and the look of the character. I have only few things to recommend.

It would be great to have a back button or a help button to let the person know what they are trying to do. I accidently hit the next button and could not go back to the first page. Was not sure what I should do in the indicator and budget page. Hope you will have more information coming up with it.

Can’t wait to see your finished project!


Regards,
Jea H. Choi

----------------------------------
Jea H. Choi

Master's Student
Instructional Design and Development
University of Georgia


Web Graduate Assistant
University Housing of UGA
Russell Hall

cjh9123@uga.edu , cjh9123@hotmail.com

#1 - Desk Crit (Recieved)

from kjrok50@uga.edu
to Natasha Barreto
date Thu, Oct 30, 2008 at 3:57 PM
subject Re: Desk Crit for your Jigsaw Puzzle

Hi~ Natasha~!

Thank you for your feedback.^^
Anyway, I'm sorry to reply lately.
Here is my short desk crit. Please, understand me if you don't understand some words.^^ If there were some error in my sentence, you could correct it.
------------------------------------------
Hi~ Natasha,
I saw the first draft of your project, the city planner. When I read your journal at first, I just thought that your idea was very logical and well organized.However, after I saw the first draft of your project, I really want to see your finished product. The color chosen in your project is really matched each other; you have a good sense of color If I suggest one thing, before the instructor of your project speak comments, I would like to look around the office for a while. Also, if you decorate your comment box, it seems to look better. Now, I'm curious about your project. I hope that I can see your project as soon as possible.

Entry # 8 – Reviewing

The showcase night was a great experience though I was nervous about my project. It made me realize that I also need to work on the presentation for my project to the public. I learned in the showcase that you should be ready to answer questions and explain how you built your project while people explore it. In the dress rehearsal, I was sort of taken by surprise with all the questions. However I was really happy to hear what people had to say about City Planner. I enjoyed explaining how the idea for it came up and what are the final development stages to get it ready for the final showcase. I also loved hearing comments on my project. I felt great to be sharing something I have worked so hard on this semester.

I was amazed with all the display of wonderful projects and ideas in the dress rehearsal. Hearing other people talking about their projects helped me feel better about my project. It felt good to share our challenges and our victories so far. And although sometimes I feel awkward to give people comments and advice on the projects, they seemed very open to opinions and eager to hear whatever I had to say about their project. There is no doubt that the dress rehearsal was a very enriching experience for all the students in the class.

As for the next steps before the “real” showcase, I plan to keep working on the final details for City Planner. I know I don’t have a lot of time, so I will have to make the right choices now and develop what it absolutely necessary. I can’t waste time working on things that are not going to add much to the final project. I have to concentrate on the “instruction” section, finalize texts and provide a final activity/feedback for the user. Sometimes I think that I could be working on this project for a long time trying to make it better, tweaking here and there. I realize there is a limit for I can do for the showcase and I am going to do the best I can.

Also during the dress rehearsal, I was seeing how people used City Planner, the doubts they had and how they interacted with it. One of my biggest concerns is how to make City Planner an interactive application, not only dynamic and animated. My challenge, as Sims (1995) describe is “to make best use of the technology, not to replicate human behavior and communication, but to enhance human-computer communications--and this is what interactivity is all about”. I have tried my best to go in the right direction with City Planner and that is why I was happy to hear what people had to say about it. Even though there is a lot that I wish I had time to develop, I think City Planner has so far been a good use of technology for interaction.

-------------------------------------------

Reference

Sims, R. (1995). Interactivity: A Forgotten Art? ITFORUM [electronic listserv]. Athens, GA: The University of Georgia. Available: http://it.coe.uga.edu/itforum/paper10/paper10.html

Thursday, November 13, 2008

#4 - Desk Crit

Date: Wed 12 Nov 21:47:41 EST 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Re: Desk Crits
To: Carolina Robinson


Hi Carolina,

Thanks for letting me comment on your project. I think your scrapbook looks very good. I like the colors, the little figures, and the arrangement of text and images. I also like the spontaneous aspect of the pictures you selected to be in your scrapbook. Your daughter look so beautiful and you have such a lovely family. You did a great job with your project and I can tell that you put a lot of love and hard work in it.

I only have a few suggestions for your project. They are for your consideration.

1) I noticed that you haven’t named the scrapbook page. When I open it on my browser, it shows “Untitled Document” on the top of my browser. You may want to change that to facilitate the browsing of your site.

2) I think it would also look good if you made the button’s appearance change in response to mouse events (i.e. up, over, and down).

Well, I think that’s it for now. You did a great job, and I look forward to seeing your final work soon! Please feel free to critique my project too. Your suggestions and comments are most welcome.

Thanks,

Natasha

Entry # 7 – Dress Rehearsal

This week has been about hard work. I have done some minor modifications on City Planner and I think it is good to go for the dress rehearsal. I did not want to put a lot of work into it before the all the feedback I am going to receive today. I think my project is on a strategic point now, as I get more desk critiques today, I will be able to reorganize some aspects of my project to get it looking good for the showcase.

I feel like I have more to do as far as engaging my audience. I need to create a good design that can communicate with users to through City Planner’s interface. People that have played with City Planner tell me they want to hear more about the scenario where the activity happens. I agree with them, there is a lot more to be done as far as constructing an introductory context that can be explored by users.
I also need to better City Planner’s navigation capabilities, so that the narrative can flow and users can enjoy participating in the activity. I also have to take into consideration how the stakeholders for this project will respond to my design. I can only imagine their expectations and interpretations for this project, but I will definitely have to get together with some engineers and planners to hear their thoughts on this.

I read an interesting book chapter this week: “Paul Rand: Using Context to Create Meaning” by Barbara Sudick. It is the 17th chapter of Designing Effective Communications: Creating Contexts for Clarity and Meaning (2006) a book I have had for quite some time now. In this specific chapter, I found a very good discussion on communicational spaces and the potential of visual language. Sudick talks about the work of t American graphic designer, Paul Rand. According to Sudick, “Rand made visual problems more creative, dramatic, and engaging with mnemonics: pictures puzzles and memory games that require the participation and challenge viewers to discover solutions.” (p. 189).

I was delighted with this discussion on communicational spaces. Even though the author did not focus on possibilities for education in these spaces, I can see the link there. Koschmann (1994) added: “what characterizes collaborative learning is a model of instruction that honors other types of communication (i.e, peer-to-peer, student-to-teacher) in addition to other traditional one-way communication of teacher to student. A theory of communication is central, therefore, to a theory of collaborative learning.” (p. 223)

------------------------------------

References:
Chapter 17 of Frascara, J. (2006). Designing Effective Communications:Creating Contexts for Clarity and Meaning. Allworth Press: New York.

Koschmann, T. (1994). Toward a theory of computer support for collaborative learning. The Journal of the Learning Sciences 3(3), 219-225.