Sunday, December 7, 2008
#9 - Reflection
The process of designing and developing City Planner was definitely a learning experience. At first it seemed like I had it all in my head and that everything would go smoothly. Then, I realized that City Planner was more like Pandora’s box. I soon found out that there were many things I had to deal with, things I had not thought of. During the process of development, I felt I was doing multiple things at the same time to make sure I could deliver the project on time, however I was following my plan and working by a method that I thought that would work (and it did). As Rowland (1993) stated, “The design process is dependent on the designer and on what he or she designs. The design process will be affected by many factors, among them the designer's knowledge, skill, and experience; the design task; the working conditions and environment; and methods and management”(P.82)
I know City Planner has many limitations, and they are important limitations. I never intended to create a perfect simulation of the impact of transportation systems on a region. My intent was to show that it is possible to build a system that can estimate this impact. Ultimately, my purpose is to make City Planner a true work of collaboration. If future engineers, professors, or local governments can research about their city environment, they can create their own formulas for measuring the impact of transportation systems and then insert them on City Planner’s system. The idea is to keep this project going and to make it flexible and reusable for both academic and governmental use.
As Nelson and Stolterman (2003) discussed “A design is always a composition. To design is to be creative and innovative, but more importantly, design is to cause things and/or people to stand together as a unified whole - a composition. Creating such a system of unification means bringing parts, pieces, functions, structures, processes and forms together in such a way that they have a presence and make an appearance, particularly of unity, in the world. Composing is an integration of several strategies of unification. These strategies use rules of relationships (protocols), in the creation of compounds, functional assemblies, patterns, systems and wholes.”(P.207)
As of the end of this semester, I am satisfied with City Planner. However, my plans for this project are to keep on making it better and more interactive. It was enriching experience to be able to share my design project with others and to learn from them. I am looking forward to studio 6200!
----------------------------------------------
References:
Rowland, G. (1993). Designing Instructional Design. Educational Technology Research and Development, 41(1), 79-91.
Nelson, H. & Stolterman, E. (2003). The design way. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: Educational Technology Publications. (Chapter 9: Composition)
Tuesday, November 25, 2008
Entry # 8 – Reviewing
I was amazed with all the display of wonderful projects and ideas in the dress rehearsal. Hearing other people talking about their projects helped me feel better about my project. It felt good to share our challenges and our victories so far. And although sometimes I feel awkward to give people comments and advice on the projects, they seemed very open to opinions and eager to hear whatever I had to say about their project. There is no doubt that the dress rehearsal was a very enriching experience for all the students in the class.
As for the next steps before the “real” showcase, I plan to keep working on the final details for City Planner. I know I don’t have a lot of time, so I will have to make the right choices now and develop what it absolutely necessary. I can’t waste time working on things that are not going to add much to the final project. I have to concentrate on the “instruction” section, finalize texts and provide a final activity/feedback for the user. Sometimes I think that I could be working on this project for a long time trying to make it better, tweaking here and there. I realize there is a limit for I can do for the showcase and I am going to do the best I can.
Also during the dress rehearsal, I was seeing how people used City Planner, the doubts they had and how they interacted with it. One of my biggest concerns is how to make City Planner an interactive application, not only dynamic and animated. My challenge, as Sims (1995) describe is “to make best use of the technology, not to replicate human behavior and communication, but to enhance human-computer communications--and this is what interactivity is all about”. I have tried my best to go in the right direction with City Planner and that is why I was happy to hear what people had to say about it. Even though there is a lot that I wish I had time to develop, I think City Planner has so far been a good use of technology for interaction.
-------------------------------------------
Reference
Sims, R. (1995). Interactivity: A Forgotten Art? ITFORUM [electronic listserv]. Athens, GA: The University of Georgia. Available: http://it.coe.uga.edu/itforum/paper10/paper10.html
Thursday, November 13, 2008
Entry # 7 – Dress Rehearsal
I feel like I have more to do as far as engaging my audience. I need to create a good design that can communicate with users to through City Planner’s interface. People that have played with City Planner tell me they want to hear more about the scenario where the activity happens. I agree with them, there is a lot more to be done as far as constructing an introductory context that can be explored by users.
I also need to better City Planner’s navigation capabilities, so that the narrative can flow and users can enjoy participating in the activity. I also have to take into consideration how the stakeholders for this project will respond to my design. I can only imagine their expectations and interpretations for this project, but I will definitely have to get together with some engineers and planners to hear their thoughts on this.
I read an interesting book chapter this week: “Paul Rand: Using Context to Create Meaning” by Barbara Sudick. It is the 17th chapter of Designing Effective Communications: Creating Contexts for Clarity and Meaning (2006) a book I have had for quite some time now. In this specific chapter, I found a very good discussion on communicational spaces and the potential of visual language. Sudick talks about the work of t American graphic designer, Paul Rand. According to Sudick, “Rand made visual problems more creative, dramatic, and engaging with mnemonics: pictures puzzles and memory games that require the participation and challenge viewers to discover solutions.” (p. 189).
I was delighted with this discussion on communicational spaces. Even though the author did not focus on possibilities for education in these spaces, I can see the link there. Koschmann (1994) added: “what characterizes collaborative learning is a model of instruction that honors other types of communication (i.e, peer-to-peer, student-to-teacher) in addition to other traditional one-way communication of teacher to student. A theory of communication is central, therefore, to a theory of collaborative learning.” (p. 223)
------------------------------------
References:
Chapter 17 of Frascara, J. (2006). Designing Effective Communications:Creating Contexts for Clarity and Meaning. Allworth Press: New York.
Koschmann, T. (1994). Toward a theory of computer support for collaborative learning. The Journal of the Learning Sciences 3(3), 219-225.
Wednesday, November 5, 2008
Entry #6: Design Process and Universal Design
When designing, I try not to get too wrapped around my opinions and my views of whatever I am creating. Though, it may be easy to say this, it is certainly much more difficult to make it happen. There has to be a balance between my perspective and the recommended approach to a solving a design problem. There are so many strategies out there to help a designer to perform his or her work, but they are so broad that you could almost use them for anything. When it comes down to real scenarios and real responsibilities, a designer has to work hard to create his or her own path to getting the job done.
Lawson (1980) discussed maps of the design process. He pointed out the difficulty writers find in describing exactly, the stages a designer goes through when designing. He explained that design maps might offer very little to actual designers. “The map, such as it is, no longer suggests any firm route through the whole process. It rather resembles one of these chaotic party games where the players dash from one room of the house to another simply in order to discover where they must go next. It is about as much help in navigating a designer through his task as a diagram showing how to walk would be to a one year old child. Knowing that design consists of analysis, synthesis, and evaluation linked in an iterative cycle will no more enable you to design than knowing the movements of breaststroke will prevent you from sinking in a swimming pool. You will just have to put it together for yourself.” (p.28)
This discussion about diagrams or maps of the design process also made me think about the Universal Design for Learning (UDL). Although it usually is mistaken with a “quest for a single, one size-fits-all, solution that will work for everyone” (Rose, 2000. p.3), UDL means exactly the opposite of that concept. Applying UDL to instructional programs means the development of multiple and flexible structures that can address learner differences.
Though UDL has principles and a framework, it is fundamentally an effort, a custom made solution “to accommodate a broad spectrum of learners, universally designed curricula require a range of options for accessing, using, and engaging with learning materials. Like universal design in architecture, with its stairs, ramps, and elevators, these alternatives reduce barriers for individuals with disabilities but also enhance opportunities for every student” (Rose & Meyer, 2002).
--------------------
References:
Lawson, B. (1980). How designers think. London: The Architectural Press, Ltd.(Chapter 3: Descriptions of the design process.)
Rose, D. H. Universal design for learning. Journal of Special Education
Technology v. 15 no. 1 (Winter 2000) p. 67-70
Chapter 4 of Rose, D.H. & Meyer, A. (2002). Teaching Every Student in the Digital Age: Universal Design for Learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.[On-line]. Available: http://www.cast.org/teachingeverystudent/ideas/tes/
Thursday, October 30, 2008
#5 - Design Experience
I tend to get confused sometimes with having so many different media involved - journal entries (Blog), Moodle (CMS), Digitization requirement (Video) , Flash (Multimedia), Desk Critiques (Email/Blog). I am also the kind of person that likes to get things done at once and done right. Unfortunately, I have not been able to be like that. I don‘t have the time to focus on what I think it is important (at least to me), my individual project. I have to take the time to think of all the other things going on and that is taking up a lot of my time.
I decided to read again the studio experience article*. That got me thinking of what a friend told me once. He said that people don’t realize how much work is involved into constructionist learning experiences. I agreed with him then, but I feel like I understand him better now. There are those who think that learner-centered (or learner-directed) approaches are easier on the learner. But they don’t realize is that such approach requires a lot of work and responsibility on the part of the learner.
Norman (1996) discussed that perspectives of the design process vary from academia to industry. “Business concerns deal with profit and loss. Innovative products do not necessarily succeed in the marketplace, and no company can afford to bring out unsuccessful products.”(P.235) In his article, Norman emphasized how important organizational structures are to developing good products. He also stresses the importance of being able to communicate problems and solutions effectively. Additionally, managing design work individually is a very different from the design process that happens in groups.
I believe that even though the world of design is an exciting and adventurous place, it requires loads of work and responsibility. The designer needs to know the importance of the chances to be taken and the ideas to be convened.
Project Update:
Project (draft) temporary location: http://natoxica.myweb.uga.edu/cityplanner.html
I have finally uploaded a functional draft version of my project. It still needs a lot of work, but it is getting there. Next steps are: Developing and organizing the texts for the speech balloons and creating instructions for the user.
----------------------------
References:
*Clinton, G., & Rieber, L.P. (2008). The Studio Experience at the University of Georgia: An example of constructionist learning for adults. Unpublished manuscript.
Norman, D. (1996). Design as practiced. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 233-247). New York: Addison-Wesley.
Thursday, October 23, 2008
#4 - More Development
Recently I listened to two very interesting podcasts from our 6190 resources list. Being an avid gamer, I immensely enjoyed listening to Henry Jenkins and Clark Aldrich talk about games, simulations, and learning. It was very refreshing to hear those presentations when I am used to hearing people saying all kinds of derogatory comments to games, especially video games.
Jenkins (2004) presented the idea that “a game is not just a game”. As he discussed during his speech, games provide much more than just entertainment, they can provide support to educational programs and function as a learning tool. He classified games as “Edutaiment”, as he believes that games are a blend of the educational and entertainment spheres. An interesting point he presented and that I find particularly interesting is that games do an excellent job at providing context for learning episodes.
In fact, he even said that games are more like field trips where students are exploring, investigating, creating, formulating ideas and making decision. That is exactly what I want my Flash Application to do. I want students to be able to play with the possibilities “City Planner” will offer and make their own assumptions.
In my project, students will have a role, they will be the transportation planner for the city of “Emanon”. My idea is as Jenkins described in his speech: to allow students to make decisions based on incomplete information. In this process it is important to have a teacher as well, but his or hers role will be of a coach or an advisor rather than the lecturer or the provider of solutions.
Aldrich (2004) discussed that we have been programmed to think linearly when developing instructional programs. However, to create simulations we need to break free from those linear structures and build new flexible instructional scenarios that allow learner interaction.
In his speech, Aldrich referred to simulations as part of a system-based concept. Interestingly, this relates so much with what I want my project to become. I want it to be dynamic, engaging, and provide a space where students can learn and develop new skills by manipulating and experimenting.
----------------------------------
References
Jenkins, Henry. 2004. Videogames and education. Tech Nation interview. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail435.html
Aldrich, Clark. 2004. Simulations and the future of learning. Presentation made at the 2004 Accelerating Change conference. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail372.html
Thursday, October 9, 2008
#2 - Creative Process
1-I have had some interesting ideas for my project name; however, I decided to wait another week until I have more of the project materials done. Once I can see the direction where the project is going I will probably be able to choose a name that will suit it.
2-I took a look at the calendar and started to account the time available for this project and the hours I will have per week to work on it. The initial phase of my designing process has been going slow, though I do not think this is a bad thing. This is the time to make ideas clear and choose a path to follow, so I guess I can afford to spend a little more time now then to have serious issues with the development stage later on. Time is also a very important aspect to my next point, the scope of work.
3-I created an outline of the scope of work and the content of the flash application. I thought about the screens, how the content and instructions would be presented, and decided on a character who is going to be the “spokesperson” for the activities.
Shahaf Gal (1996) interestingly depicted the configurations of the design process. In his article “Footholds for Design”, learning is not conceived in unproblematic situations. Likewise, the design process occurs from the relationships among materials, experiments, project participants, and challenging situations. He sees the activity of designing materials as the extreme sport of rock climbing. The designer, much like the rock climber, has to make decisions based on the previously chosen trajectories and on his or her personal strategies to get safely to the next stage.
Designing an application, like the one I am developing, Gal’s ideas can be very helpful. Being the designer requires the ability to develop strategies that will lead to the accomplishment of target objectives. Selecting strategies and supportive technology is a task that must be performed seriously and especially, intentionally.
Agenda for upcoming weeks:
1)Keep thinking about a name for the project.
2)Start developing the screens and the flash application.
-------------------------------
References:
Gal, S. (1996). Footholds for design. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 215-227). New York: Addison-Wesley.
Thursday, October 2, 2008
#1 - Project Description
I must be focusing on the behavioral aspect of my project’s design as Norman (2004) would describe it. I am currently reviewing its functionality, its purpose and structure.
I understand the process of designing is a real conundrum, like playing soduko. There are many aspects that need to be taken into account and planned for. It is also important to be able to let ideas “simmer” for some time until they have been thoroughly analyzed and are ready to be developed on. Working independently though, seems to be a lot harder. I have Learning Object design experience on a team. There may be some difficulties in working as a group, though, Kapor (1996) described communicational issues that may occur among self-titled designers and programmers, I have to say form my experience that the design process flows a lot smoother when you have more people working on it.
I tried to used elements of ADDIE process to help me organize my ideas. Please see a summary of my project below:
Project context:
Access to petroleum has once again become an issue, as such, communities, local governments and individuals try to migrate from motor vehicles to less petroleum dependant means of transportation. In addition, there has been a rise in awareness of the impact of motor vehicle emissions to communities’ air quality.
Although there is a clear movement for greener transportation systems, governments seem to stumble on the processes of developing and implementing low environmental impact strategies. The main reason for this is that transportation systems have major ties to industry, commerce, and people’s lives. Though motor vehicles carry negative consequences to the environment and impose dependency on the suppliers of petroleum, they have grown with the needs of our society and have brought through the years consequences and implications that cannot be underestimated.
The Purpose:
The reason for this project is to provide a Flash application that helps the learner audience specified below to identify, interpret, and associate costs and benefits related to transportation modes.
Learner Audience:
- Students in transportation planning and engineering.
- Metropolitan Planning Organizations (MPO’s) decision-makers/staff.
- Urbanized city and counties transportation decision-makers/staff.
Instructional Goals:
- The reason for this project is to provide an application that helps users to:
- Interpret the consequences related to investments on specific transportation systems.
- Identify the effects and costs of transportation policies.
- Associate the following factors: Pollution, Oil Consumption, Local Development, and Travel Time to specific transportation systems choices.
The benefits of the project:
- Engage learners in the task of developing cleaner and effective transportation strategies.
- Encourage local governments, cities, and counties to consider the benefits of alternative means of transportation.
- Promote reflection among learners for the creation of transportation strategies that would benefit the global population.
Project Agenda:
1)Create the scope of work and a name for the project.
2)Content selection.
3)Create a storyboard for the events in the application.
4)Design the visual components of the application.
5)Build interface.
6)Generate a prototype.
7)Review all products.
8)Present products.
Resources:
1)Equipment specification for project development:
Laptop Computer
Processor speed: 2.66 GHz
Memory: 4GB
Operating System: Windows XP Professional
Hard Drive: 80GB
Display size: 17" diagonal WXGA
Wireless: Wireless 1350 WLAN (802.11 b/g, 54 Mbps)
2)Software for project development:
- Adobe Design Premium Suite CS3 (which includes Adobe’s: Acrobat, Dreamweaver, Flash, Illustrator, and Photoshop).
- Microsoft Office Suite 2007 (which includes Microsoft’s: Word, PowerPoint, and Excel).
3)Human Resources:
Natasha Barreto - Project Developer.
Robert Sills – Subject Matter Expert.
-------------------------------
References:
Kapor, M. (1996). A software design manifesto. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 1-9). New York: Addison-Wesley.
Norman, D. (2004). Emotional Design: Why We Love (Or Hate) Everyday Things. New York: Basic Books.
Wednesday, September 24, 2008
Initial Thoughts
These past few weeks I have put a lot of time into thinking of interesting ideas for my project. It took a little more reflection time than what I thought it would, but I am happy I have finally found an idea that inspires me. Before I go ahead and talk about my project idea for the 6190 class, I would also like to share some ideas and thoughts I had while I was brainstorming.
Initially, I thought about creating an animation, but that fell through quite quickly. Animations are very powerful, and a lot of effort goes into creating good scenarios, characters, and making clear representations of events. Unfortunately, if they are not built to follow a purpose and communicate interesting information, they can easily become disposable. Not to say that other materials don’t require to be purpose orientated and communicative, however animation allows for multiple interpretations (what is just fine if that is what one is looking for), though, in my opinion, it works better when it is connected to a series of events that the user can interpret and then manipulate.
From then on, I could see that I wanted to develop something that somebody may use someday, even if it needs adjustments or further development (I work better when I know that my project is not going to be put into a folder, later to be filed, and then forgotten). So, I knew my project had to allow for user interaction. It could be a simulation, a game, a dynamic database or things of the sort, but had to be a dynamic and engaging experience.
Once I knew the direction I wanted to go, ideas started pouring in, and I at last saw something that had potential. Please take a look at my project description.
