It seems there is a very thin line between the right and wrong use of technology in educational programs. It is hard not to be biased when one knows the possibilities a tool can offer. I often find myself tempted to develop instruction around the “cool” features of new software I recently found out about. However, I also know an instructional designer has to make decisions based on facts rather than on personal preferences.
When designing, I try not to get too wrapped around my opinions and my views of whatever I am creating. Though, it may be easy to say this, it is certainly much more difficult to make it happen. There has to be a balance between my perspective and the recommended approach to a solving a design problem. There are so many strategies out there to help a designer to perform his or her work, but they are so broad that you could almost use them for anything. When it comes down to real scenarios and real responsibilities, a designer has to work hard to create his or her own path to getting the job done.
Lawson (1980) discussed maps of the design process. He pointed out the difficulty writers find in describing exactly, the stages a designer goes through when designing. He explained that design maps might offer very little to actual designers. “The map, such as it is, no longer suggests any firm route through the whole process. It rather resembles one of these chaotic party games where the players dash from one room of the house to another simply in order to discover where they must go next. It is about as much help in navigating a designer through his task as a diagram showing how to walk would be to a one year old child. Knowing that design consists of analysis, synthesis, and evaluation linked in an iterative cycle will no more enable you to design than knowing the movements of breaststroke will prevent you from sinking in a swimming pool. You will just have to put it together for yourself.” (p.28)
This discussion about diagrams or maps of the design process also made me think about the Universal Design for Learning (UDL). Although it usually is mistaken with a “quest for a single, one size-fits-all, solution that will work for everyone” (Rose, 2000. p.3), UDL means exactly the opposite of that concept. Applying UDL to instructional programs means the development of multiple and flexible structures that can address learner differences.
Though UDL has principles and a framework, it is fundamentally an effort, a custom made solution “to accommodate a broad spectrum of learners, universally designed curricula require a range of options for accessing, using, and engaging with learning materials. Like universal design in architecture, with its stairs, ramps, and elevators, these alternatives reduce barriers for individuals with disabilities but also enhance opportunities for every student” (Rose & Meyer, 2002).
--------------------
References:
Lawson, B. (1980). How designers think. London: The Architectural Press, Ltd.(Chapter 3: Descriptions of the design process.)
Rose, D. H. Universal design for learning. Journal of Special Education
Technology v. 15 no. 1 (Winter 2000) p. 67-70
Chapter 4 of Rose, D.H. & Meyer, A. (2002). Teaching Every Student in the Digital Age: Universal Design for Learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.[On-line]. Available: http://www.cast.org/teachingeverystudent/ideas/tes/