Showing posts with label Desk Crit. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Desk Crit. Show all posts

Thursday, November 13, 2008

#4 - Desk Crit

Date: Wed 12 Nov 21:47:41 EST 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Re: Desk Crits
To: Carolina Robinson


Hi Carolina,

Thanks for letting me comment on your project. I think your scrapbook looks very good. I like the colors, the little figures, and the arrangement of text and images. I also like the spontaneous aspect of the pictures you selected to be in your scrapbook. Your daughter look so beautiful and you have such a lovely family. You did a great job with your project and I can tell that you put a lot of love and hard work in it.

I only have a few suggestions for your project. They are for your consideration.

1) I noticed that you haven’t named the scrapbook page. When I open it on my browser, it shows “Untitled Document” on the top of my browser. You may want to change that to facilitate the browsing of your site.

2) I think it would also look good if you made the button’s appearance change in response to mouse events (i.e. up, over, and down).

Well, I think that’s it for now. You did a great job, and I look forward to seeing your final work soon! Please feel free to critique my project too. Your suggestions and comments are most welcome.

Thanks,

Natasha

Monday, November 3, 2008

#3 - Desk Crit

Date: Wed 29 Oct 19:49:39 EDT 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Desk Critique for your Melissa's Travelogue
To: melissa.g.gay@gmail.com


Hi Melissa,

I think your project is “beautiful”. I like everything about it, and most of all, I like hearing you talk about it. You seem very passionate about your experience in Bolivia and your project mirrors that feeling.

The other day during class, you were showing me some of the images you are going to be using for your project. I like the colors, the sceneries, and especially your perspective of that country.

In general, you did an awesome job so far for your project. If you permit, I may just give you a couple of tips for your Melissa’s Travelogue. These are for your consideration:

1)I think your website would look even better if you removed the horizontal bars on the top and bottom of the screen and centered the hole site to the middle of the page. You could also create a pattern to apply to your entire site background, like you did by the book sides on the main page. I think it would make it stand out more like a real book than a website.

2)You may want to visit this site: http://browsershots.org/
It generates images of how your site will look in older browsers and platforms (PC vs. MAC). It helps us find bugs in the CSS sheets and incompatibilities with navigators.

Well, I think that’s it for now. Thanks for letting me critique your project. You did a fantastic job!

Thanks,
Natasha

#2 - Desk Crit

Date: Tue 28 Oct 22:25:00 EDT 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Desk Crit for your Jigsaw Puzzle
To: kjrok50@uga.edu


Hi Jungrok,

Thanks for letting me write you a desk critique. First of all, I’d like to congratulate you for taking the challenge of learning both Flash and Actionscript for this project.

I have seen you walking around with the “Learn Flash in 24 hours” book and I know you have been working hard in your project.

If you allow me, I would like to make a few comments about your Jigsaw Puzzle game.

1)I really liked the design of your 6190 personal page. Very appealing and it matches your project perfectly.

2)Your Jigsaw Puzzle is turning out very nicely. I liked the images you chose for the puzzles and I am curious to see the fully functional version of your game.

3)One suggestion for your consideration is to use just one font style throughout the game . I noticed you have two types of fonts going (other than your top logo font) and it might be a good idea to pick one and stick with it.

4)Just a quick tip for you: you might find great video tutorials on Youtube that can help you work on the next stages of your jigsaw puzzle. This one I’m sending you teaches how to create click and drag flash movies - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZiAX9LfHXM

I think your idea is great and your project looks fantastic. Like I said, I can’t wait to see the final version of it.

Thanks,

Natasha

#1 - Desk Crit

Date: Tue 28 Oct 15:12:06 EDT 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Desk Crit for Disc Golf Website
To: sean0609@uga.edu


Hi Sean,

Like we discussed briefly before the 6190 studio class last week, I think your project is an excellent idea. Not only are you building a site and learning to develop web-based content, but it seems you are also having fun talking about a sport that you enjoy.

I must admit that after visiting your website I started to realize that disc golf is not that rare around here. I went to a park in Peachtree City and saw what you call a “basket”. Though it may not be a common sport for most Americans, it is definitely something I had never heard of before. In that sense, your website helped me identify the equipment and the basic rules necessary to play disc golf.

If you allow me, I would like to make a few comments about your Disc Golf Website. The points I will list below are for your consideration.

1)I noticed you recently revamped the site’s appearance. It looks good, I especially like the grassy background. However, I think you should consider organizing a space for the text and images. The home.html needs to look a little bit more like the about.html.

2)I think you should also consider adding a little more contrast to your text. The headers are good and readable because they are large and bold. Though where you have a lot of text it is hard to read a small font green on that orange-like background.

3) I don’t know if you are going to have time for this, but if you do, it would be good to add a loader to your Flash application embedded in course.html. I guess it helps people with slower connections see that something is going to appear there, instead of getting only a blank page while the Flash application loads.

4) I guess it would also be a good idea to add titles to your html documents. It will only take you a minute and it will help viewers recognize your website in case they have different tabs open. It is also very important to have titles if you want users want to bookmark your site or add it to their social bookmarking accounts.

Well, I think that is it. I will just give you one last tip. You may want to see how your website will look in different platforms and make sure it is compatible with different browsers. Here’s a good website to look at that: http://browsershots.org/

Please let me know if there is anything I can help you with your project and if you need clarifications on my comments.

Thanks,
Natasha