Tuesday, November 25, 2008

#3 - Desk Crit (Recieved)

from Sean Boyle
to natoxica@uga.edu
date Fri, Nov 14, 2008 at 10:25 AM
subject Desk Crit


Hi Natasha,
Thanks for letting me take a look at your project. I think it looks really great. The colors and layout are excellent and your animation and drawing skills are great - especially Joe! I can tell that you are really passionate about your subject as well as the educational concepts/theory behind the project. It does remind me of the Sim City concept and I like the fact that you are giving users the power to control their budget/citizen happiness and see the direct result of changes on each.

I know you are still in the process of creating this but I might offer a few suggestions:

1. Maybe some more explanation of the indicators (a rollover definition perhaps). I know the pollution, taxes and travel time are pretty obvious but the fourth may not be. And also, certain users who are less aware/knowledgeable of these concepts may need an explanation of all four.

2. I know you're probably working on the feedback section but I wanted to comment that an explanation of why an increase of a certain investment line affects the budget and citizen satisfaction would be useful as well. For instance, an increase in cars raises pollution and lowers travel time/local development. An explanation of exactly why would be useful for visitors.

3. I know you mentioned you were planning on creating further explanations of each investment area. I think that's a great idea and takes the site beyond a learning tool about budgets and then adds a public awareness/education component that will be really great.

Overall, I think the site looks excellent and I'm looking forward to seeing it at the Showcase.

Take care,
Sean

No comments: