Wednesday, November 5, 2008

#3 - Service Hours



I'm now developing some of the scenarios for Fantastic Stories. They need it all done by the end of the month and I hope I can make the remaining screens and scenarios in time. Above is one of the screens I made recently.
We had a meeting last week and made sure that we are all on the same page. There is a lot to get done and very little time.

Entry #6: Design Process and Universal Design

It seems there is a very thin line between the right and wrong use of technology in educational programs. It is hard not to be biased when one knows the possibilities a tool can offer. I often find myself tempted to develop instruction around the “cool” features of new software I recently found out about. However, I also know an instructional designer has to make decisions based on facts rather than on personal preferences.

When designing, I try not to get too wrapped around my opinions and my views of whatever I am creating. Though, it may be easy to say this, it is certainly much more difficult to make it happen. There has to be a balance between my perspective and the recommended approach to a solving a design problem. There are so many strategies out there to help a designer to perform his or her work, but they are so broad that you could almost use them for anything. When it comes down to real scenarios and real responsibilities, a designer has to work hard to create his or her own path to getting the job done.

Lawson (1980) discussed maps of the design process. He pointed out the difficulty writers find in describing exactly, the stages a designer goes through when designing. He explained that design maps might offer very little to actual designers. “The map, such as it is, no longer suggests any firm route through the whole process. It rather resembles one of these chaotic party games where the players dash from one room of the house to another simply in order to discover where they must go next. It is about as much help in navigating a designer through his task as a diagram showing how to walk would be to a one year old child. Knowing that design consists of analysis, synthesis, and evaluation linked in an iterative cycle will no more enable you to design than knowing the movements of breaststroke will prevent you from sinking in a swimming pool. You will just have to put it together for yourself.” (p.28)

This discussion about diagrams or maps of the design process also made me think about the Universal Design for Learning (UDL). Although it usually is mistaken with a “quest for a single, one size-fits-all, solution that will work for everyone” (Rose, 2000. p.3), UDL means exactly the opposite of that concept. Applying UDL to instructional programs means the development of multiple and flexible structures that can address learner differences.

Though UDL has principles and a framework, it is fundamentally an effort, a custom made solution “to accommodate a broad spectrum of learners, universally designed curricula require a range of options for accessing, using, and engaging with learning materials. Like universal design in architecture, with its stairs, ramps, and elevators, these alternatives reduce barriers for individuals with disabilities but also enhance opportunities for every student” (Rose & Meyer, 2002).

--------------------
References:

Lawson, B. (1980). How designers think. London: The Architectural Press, Ltd.(Chapter 3: Descriptions of the design process.)

Rose, D. H. Universal design for learning. Journal of Special Education
Technology v. 15 no. 1 (Winter 2000) p. 67-70

Chapter 4 of Rose, D.H. & Meyer, A. (2002). Teaching Every Student in the Digital Age: Universal Design for Learning. Alexandria, VA: Association for Supervision and Curriculum Development.[On-line]. Available: http://www.cast.org/teachingeverystudent/ideas/tes/

Monday, November 3, 2008

#3 - Desk Crit

Date: Wed 29 Oct 19:49:39 EDT 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Desk Critique for your Melissa's Travelogue
To: melissa.g.gay@gmail.com


Hi Melissa,

I think your project is “beautiful”. I like everything about it, and most of all, I like hearing you talk about it. You seem very passionate about your experience in Bolivia and your project mirrors that feeling.

The other day during class, you were showing me some of the images you are going to be using for your project. I like the colors, the sceneries, and especially your perspective of that country.

In general, you did an awesome job so far for your project. If you permit, I may just give you a couple of tips for your Melissa’s Travelogue. These are for your consideration:

1)I think your website would look even better if you removed the horizontal bars on the top and bottom of the screen and centered the hole site to the middle of the page. You could also create a pattern to apply to your entire site background, like you did by the book sides on the main page. I think it would make it stand out more like a real book than a website.

2)You may want to visit this site: http://browsershots.org/
It generates images of how your site will look in older browsers and platforms (PC vs. MAC). It helps us find bugs in the CSS sheets and incompatibilities with navigators.

Well, I think that’s it for now. Thanks for letting me critique your project. You did a fantastic job!

Thanks,
Natasha

#2 - Desk Crit

Date: Tue 28 Oct 22:25:00 EDT 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Desk Crit for your Jigsaw Puzzle
To: kjrok50@uga.edu


Hi Jungrok,

Thanks for letting me write you a desk critique. First of all, I’d like to congratulate you for taking the challenge of learning both Flash and Actionscript for this project.

I have seen you walking around with the “Learn Flash in 24 hours” book and I know you have been working hard in your project.

If you allow me, I would like to make a few comments about your Jigsaw Puzzle game.

1)I really liked the design of your 6190 personal page. Very appealing and it matches your project perfectly.

2)Your Jigsaw Puzzle is turning out very nicely. I liked the images you chose for the puzzles and I am curious to see the fully functional version of your game.

3)One suggestion for your consideration is to use just one font style throughout the game . I noticed you have two types of fonts going (other than your top logo font) and it might be a good idea to pick one and stick with it.

4)Just a quick tip for you: you might find great video tutorials on Youtube that can help you work on the next stages of your jigsaw puzzle. This one I’m sending you teaches how to create click and drag flash movies - http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xZiAX9LfHXM

I think your idea is great and your project looks fantastic. Like I said, I can’t wait to see the final version of it.

Thanks,

Natasha

#1 - Desk Crit

Date: Tue 28 Oct 15:12:06 EDT 2008
From: Natasha Barreto Add To Address Book | This is Spam
Subject: Desk Crit for Disc Golf Website
To: sean0609@uga.edu


Hi Sean,

Like we discussed briefly before the 6190 studio class last week, I think your project is an excellent idea. Not only are you building a site and learning to develop web-based content, but it seems you are also having fun talking about a sport that you enjoy.

I must admit that after visiting your website I started to realize that disc golf is not that rare around here. I went to a park in Peachtree City and saw what you call a “basket”. Though it may not be a common sport for most Americans, it is definitely something I had never heard of before. In that sense, your website helped me identify the equipment and the basic rules necessary to play disc golf.

If you allow me, I would like to make a few comments about your Disc Golf Website. The points I will list below are for your consideration.

1)I noticed you recently revamped the site’s appearance. It looks good, I especially like the grassy background. However, I think you should consider organizing a space for the text and images. The home.html needs to look a little bit more like the about.html.

2)I think you should also consider adding a little more contrast to your text. The headers are good and readable because they are large and bold. Though where you have a lot of text it is hard to read a small font green on that orange-like background.

3) I don’t know if you are going to have time for this, but if you do, it would be good to add a loader to your Flash application embedded in course.html. I guess it helps people with slower connections see that something is going to appear there, instead of getting only a blank page while the Flash application loads.

4) I guess it would also be a good idea to add titles to your html documents. It will only take you a minute and it will help viewers recognize your website in case they have different tabs open. It is also very important to have titles if you want users want to bookmark your site or add it to their social bookmarking accounts.

Well, I think that is it. I will just give you one last tip. You may want to see how your website will look in different platforms and make sure it is compatible with different browsers. Here’s a good website to look at that: http://browsershots.org/

Please let me know if there is anything I can help you with your project and if you need clarifications on my comments.

Thanks,
Natasha

Thursday, October 30, 2008

#5 - Design Experience

A week has gone by, but it sure feels like a decade. It has been getting busy and now, more than ever, I need to follow my agenda to finish everything on time. Unforeseen events have happened which I had not accounted for, and now I will have to reorganize my work hours to be able to get everything done.

I tend to get confused sometimes with having so many different media involved - journal entries (Blog), Moodle (CMS), Digitization requirement (Video) , Flash (Multimedia), Desk Critiques (Email/Blog). I am also the kind of person that likes to get things done at once and done right. Unfortunately, I have not been able to be like that. I don‘t have the time to focus on what I think it is important (at least to me), my individual project. I have to take the time to think of all the other things going on and that is taking up a lot of my time.

I decided to read again the studio experience article*. That got me thinking of what a friend told me once. He said that people don’t realize how much work is involved into constructionist learning experiences. I agreed with him then, but I feel like I understand him better now. There are those who think that learner-centered (or learner-directed) approaches are easier on the learner. But they don’t realize is that such approach requires a lot of work and responsibility on the part of the learner.

Norman (1996) discussed that perspectives of the design process vary from academia to industry. “Business concerns deal with profit and loss. Innovative products do not necessarily succeed in the marketplace, and no company can afford to bring out unsuccessful products.”(P.235) In his article, Norman emphasized how important organizational structures are to developing good products. He also stresses the importance of being able to communicate problems and solutions effectively. Additionally, managing design work individually is a very different from the design process that happens in groups.

I believe that even though the world of design is an exciting and adventurous place, it requires loads of work and responsibility. The designer needs to know the importance of the chances to be taken and the ideas to be convened.

Project Update:

Project (draft) temporary location: http://natoxica.myweb.uga.edu/cityplanner.html
I have finally uploaded a functional draft version of my project. It still needs a lot of work, but it is getting there. Next steps are: Developing and organizing the texts for the speech balloons and creating instructions for the user.

----------------------------
References:

*Clinton, G., & Rieber, L.P. (2008). The Studio Experience at the University of Georgia: An example of constructionist learning for adults. Unpublished manuscript.

Norman, D. (1996). Design as practiced. In Winograd, T. (Ed.), Bringing Design to Software (pp. 233-247). New York: Addison-Wesley.

Thursday, October 23, 2008

#4 - More Development

The development stage of “City Planner” has been a lot of work, but a lot of fun as well. I think that the most wonderful thing about the 6190 studio is to be able to experiment, to explore and to have a good time. At least, this is what I have been doing.
Recently I listened to two very interesting podcasts from our 6190 resources list. Being an avid gamer, I immensely enjoyed listening to Henry Jenkins and Clark Aldrich talk about games, simulations, and learning. It was very refreshing to hear those presentations when I am used to hearing people saying all kinds of derogatory comments to games, especially video games.
Jenkins (2004) presented the idea that “a game is not just a game”. As he discussed during his speech, games provide much more than just entertainment, they can provide support to educational programs and function as a learning tool. He classified games as “Edutaiment”, as he believes that games are a blend of the educational and entertainment spheres. An interesting point he presented and that I find particularly interesting is that games do an excellent job at providing context for learning episodes.
In fact, he even said that games are more like field trips where students are exploring, investigating, creating, formulating ideas and making decision. That is exactly what I want my Flash Application to do. I want students to be able to play with the possibilities “City Planner” will offer and make their own assumptions.
In my project, students will have a role, they will be the transportation planner for the city of “Emanon”. My idea is as Jenkins described in his speech: to allow students to make decisions based on incomplete information. In this process it is important to have a teacher as well, but his or hers role will be of a coach or an advisor rather than the lecturer or the provider of solutions.
Aldrich (2004) discussed that we have been programmed to think linearly when developing instructional programs. However, to create simulations we need to break free from those linear structures and build new flexible instructional scenarios that allow learner interaction.
In his speech, Aldrich referred to simulations as part of a system-based concept. Interestingly, this relates so much with what I want my project to become. I want it to be dynamic, engaging, and provide a space where students can learn and develop new skills by manipulating and experimenting.

----------------------------------
References
Jenkins, Henry. 2004. Videogames and education. Tech Nation interview. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail435.html

Aldrich, Clark. 2004. Simulations and the future of learning. Presentation made at the 2004 Accelerating Change conference. [podcast] Available: http://www.itconversations.com/shows/detail372.html